User Generated Content

Journalists Don’t Just Report News…

At the end of his lecture last week on the Hutton Report, Richard Tait suggested the media’s reportage of the current financial crisis might be worsening the problem; but what about user generated content?

They Can Create It

Two weeks ago, somebody wrote on CNN’s “unedited, unfiltered” I Report that Apple CEO Steve Jobs had suffered a heart attack. It was a false claim, but until Apple denied the story, their stock price dropped.

Although Duncan Riley said CNN failed by not moderating their content on I Report, he also said it was “a traditional stock scam… that says absolutely nothing about citizen journalism at all.”

Changing The Way We Think

UGC could make it difficult to find quality content, but what’s to say this is a bad thing?

While it may be frustrating for people to sift through a mass of UGC to find a few good stories, it could make them more critical readers.

McNae’s Essential Law for Journalists suggests a free press works to inform the public, so allows them to have an opinion and consequently freedom of speech.

I think UGC encourages people to be inquisitive, so they can become a collaborator as well as a reader.



Filed under Online Journalism Lectures

2 responses to “User Generated Content

  1. Martin Shankleman

    If someone posts an unverified and untrue fact on a website, that’s not news, it’s tittle tattle.

  2. Glyn

    We’re unused to news coming through unusual channels – but that person shouting from the rooftops about disability benefit could be a mum looking after a disabled child.

    Is her view less valid than that of a journalist? No, it is more valid. Should we tell her story, or help her frame here own?

    Filtering and framing news are important parts of what journalists do – but people talk and tell each other “news” every day.

    How that is defined is now being looked at and challenged.

    Savvy journalists working with those who send in/create data will find there is a lot of good information out there.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s